Morning Musume Members Ranking

Comments

i'll give you mine, i'll just do a top 10

1. Sayu
2. Koharu
3. Reina
4. Aika
5. Aichan
6. Yossie
7. Risa
8. Konkon
9. Makoto
10. Miki

Hey I recently heard something about Makoto and reading this has just reminded me that I know something but I cant remember what! Argh! Its frustrating! I shall have to try and remember :) As for Ribbon I've had it downloaded for ages I've just never watched it yet. I dont know why as I do really want to see it I just keep putting it of for some reason :/

Anyways putting that aside its good to hear your H!P rank list, if it wasnt for you I probably wouldnt have bothered posting mine :P Yes, I demand more Yuko and Yasuda too. Yuko's last single was OK I guess but Yasuda is hardley seen any more which is a shame :( I also didnt know that Tsunku called Konkon a failure. Thats a bit harsh saying as the amount of fans she has...

That's a nice selection ^_^ I do however notice Eri's absence. That intrigues me, since other than that there's a prevalence of kawaii members...
Tsunku said that in her audition... He said she wasn't very good, but he thought she had potential, or something like that. In fact, I still haven't seen that audition, I only heard about that in another program. Since I haven't seen it, I don't know, he might be right. I can't understand Tsunku's mind when choosing these members, I've only seen the original audition and he already had the strangest reactions... Like, when Nacchi first appeared, he passed her whole performance concentrated at the screen, and didn't say anything. Well, he did say in the end that "her way to hold the mic is good". He had praised other candidates much more. But in the end, he chose Nacchi to go to the next stage right away, without having to sing a second time. Nacchi was the only one who did that. Whatever his reasons, he tends to be right in the end.

Maybe you know that Makoto is still on touch with the H!P members because she was interviewed in that singles collection release, and that hopefully she'll come back soon?

You should really watch Ribbon no Kishi =P All their musicals are great, and Ribbon is special.
maybe I could fit her in there next time lol

I don't know how she didn't end up in my top 10 to begin with
Maybe because it's not a top 11? =P
It's impossible to fit everyone you like in 10 places T_T I would need at least 16 or 17... It's so sad to not see them all in it...
well at least she's in there somewhere lol

my top 3 has been the same for a while now

refreshing to see both Yuko and Yasuda in the mix, and I share your enthusiasm for Ogawa, a girl that left her impact when she was gone - for me at least - as it was then I realised all the fun she added to MM.

I couldn't leave Yuuko and Yasuda out, they're just too great =P Part of the reason I decided to do an "all members ever" list is because of them. They're underused/not used at all, and they never appear in these rankings, but I can't see how someone could not love them after seeing old programs they're in...
It took a while for me to realize Ogawa's role too... I only woke up when I saw her graduation at the Ribbon no Kishi concert, and then her special last episode in Hello! Morning, and there were all those segments with her... Maybe because I got to H!P later and watch so much older stuff I only realize they aren't in momusu anymore after I've seen their graduations...
You have a very diverse favorite member list! It's really nice to see Nacchi way up there too. So many reasons to love Konkon and I love your reasoning. A Makochan comeback...that'd be great to see and with Konkon returning you never can tell. :) It's great having these lists as you can look back on them later and see how things were at various points. I'm happy to see so many members included in yours! I still need to work on a complete member listing but haven't gotten around to it yet. Thanks for sharing!
Ogawa's comeback is actually way more probable than Konkon was before being announced. She's still officialy a part of H!P, since she only graduated from Morning Musume. At least according to theppn and wiki. So I'm seriously expecting her comeback.

The problem is what they'll do with her. I think there's already enough units in H!P. And I tend to see Ogawa in a similar way as Yasuda, since both of them really shined to me in those skits... I just hope if she does come back, it'll be proved I'm the only one who thinks like that, and she'll receive better treatment than Yasuda T_T

Yuko and Yasuda's importance isn't totally lost on the newer generation of fans I think, because as their interest grows they'll delve into the history, and Yasuda especially has given us great conflicts with, say, Taka-san on many Utabans haha. And Yuko's attitude is something I'm missing :P

I totally agree about giving Yuko a spot on HM@ to present the show. but the new format with the king ruins any chances of having past members on to fill that role now, and for that reason alone, I think the king should go.

Mikitty is someone I have a lot of time for too :) but I don't know, maybe I'm still in shock but, I just dont think about her anymore. I guess I dont want to confront the fact that shes MIA right now.

I wonder if Yuuko would have to use one of those animal ears, and what animal it would be... I don't know what Yuuko could add to the new format, it's just way too strange to imagine her in either of the options - the Uso Queen or the Genius Kid styles. A presentator isn't so important in this format. What I really want is to get Hello! Pro News again. They should just cut that Joker-with-the-cards thing and revive the advertising segments.
The news segment with Yukosan & Kamei reunited would make HM@ about a thousand times better! :)

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in

HarimaKenji

About Me

HarimaKenji
Brazil

Neighborhood

Explore friends, family, friends & family, or entire neighborhood.

Archives